Juniper (Phoenix Graft)
- KyleMB
-
Offline Topic Author
- New Member
-
- Posts: 16
- Thanks received: 0
Hi there
I have grafted my Juniper onto a piece of Deadwood and it has been growing happily in this state for about 2 months. Recently one of my branches has become quite dry and doesn't seem to be doing too well. I have studied the branch and it appears that it might be damaged at the junction where the branch meets the trunk. I'm not sure whether it is just struggling or whether it is dying.
Does anybody have any suggestions on how to nurture this branch back to health?
I have posted a picture of my tree below.
Regards
Kyle
I have grafted my Juniper onto a piece of Deadwood and it has been growing happily in this state for about 2 months. Recently one of my branches has become quite dry and doesn't seem to be doing too well. I have studied the branch and it appears that it might be damaged at the junction where the branch meets the trunk. I'm not sure whether it is just struggling or whether it is dying.
Does anybody have any suggestions on how to nurture this branch back to health?
I have posted a picture of my tree below.
Regards
Kyle
by KyleMB
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- manofthetrees
-
Offline
- Platinum Member
-
- Posts: 1070
- Thanks received: 193
i have broken branches sometime they make it sometimes they don't.i afraid yours doesn't look good... jin may be an option
by manofthetrees
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- KyleMB
-
Offline Topic Author
- New Member
-
- Posts: 16
- Thanks received: 0
A that is such a pity. Hopefully it survives. If it dies, I would have to jin it, or would it be possible to try to graft another branch on?
Sadly this tree only consists of a first, second and third branch and an apex. So if that branch dies, I would Only have two branches and an apex, which might look quite silly.
Thanks for the advice though.
Sadly this tree only consists of a first, second and third branch and an apex. So if that branch dies, I would Only have two branches and an apex, which might look quite silly.
Thanks for the advice though.
by KyleMB
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Leslie
-
Offline
- Platinum Member
-
- Posts: 749
- Thanks received: 7
Hi Kyle
It's very good to meet you.
I am speaking from my experience with plants and not with bonsai as I'm a newbie to the art of bonsai. I didn't know it is possible to graft live branches to dead wood however, it would seem the only way to do this successfully would be first to pre-soak the dead wood letting it absorb as much water as possible; then add rooting hormone to the ends of the branches before putting the branches into the holes. Then I would think it necessary to keep the dead wood and branches constantly damp through heavy misting with a spray bottle of water every day, two or three times a day depending on your climate/heat/sun/wind and to fertilize regualarly by spraying with a water-soluable fertilizer.
This is just my take on it however, the experts here may not agree and I hope they will correct me if I'm wrong. Best of luck!
Leslie
It's very good to meet you.
I am speaking from my experience with plants and not with bonsai as I'm a newbie to the art of bonsai. I didn't know it is possible to graft live branches to dead wood however, it would seem the only way to do this successfully would be first to pre-soak the dead wood letting it absorb as much water as possible; then add rooting hormone to the ends of the branches before putting the branches into the holes. Then I would think it necessary to keep the dead wood and branches constantly damp through heavy misting with a spray bottle of water every day, two or three times a day depending on your climate/heat/sun/wind and to fertilize regualarly by spraying with a water-soluable fertilizer.
This is just my take on it however, the experts here may not agree and I hope they will correct me if I'm wrong. Best of luck!
Leslie
by Leslie
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- KyleMB
-
Offline Topic Author
- New Member
-
- Posts: 16
- Thanks received: 0
Thank you Leslie! Very good to meet you too.
Personally, I have contact with some great 名媛直播 artists and they have given me some solid techniques to try out. Today I also found out that the Juniperus species works well for grafting new branches on.
Thank you so much for your reply and advice. I take it all into consideration. Also thank you so much for taking the time to read and reply to my queries.
Kind regards
Kyle
Personally, I have contact with some great 名媛直播 artists and they have given me some solid techniques to try out. Today I also found out that the Juniperus species works well for grafting new branches on.
Thank you so much for your reply and advice. I take it all into consideration. Also thank you so much for taking the time to read and reply to my queries.
Kind regards
Kyle
by KyleMB
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Bassand名媛直播
-
Offline
- Elite Member
-
- Posts: 180
- Thanks received: 0
It's nice to meet you, Kyle. I wouldn't be unduly worried, as trees can be incredibly resilient, but I would change my watering like Leslie said.
Also, I dig your signature. It's nice to know that someone else speaks/is learning Japanese!
Also, I dig your signature. It's nice to know that someone else speaks/is learning Japanese!
by Bassand名媛直播
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- leatherback
-
Offline
- Platinum Member
-
- Posts: 8642
- Thanks received: 3662
Hi Kyle,
Just a little doubt here. you were trying to graft onto an actual piece of dead wood? That will never work. You will need a living plant to graft upon. Otherwise you are trying to get a cutting to set root in wood, which will only work when the wood is in a serious state of decay. The reason your plant looked good is becaus juniperus is good at keeping moisture. If those so-called experts adviced you to graft upon a dead piece of wood, they are either no experts or they are pulling your leg. Sorry ..
Just a little doubt here. you were trying to graft onto an actual piece of dead wood? That will never work. You will need a living plant to graft upon. Otherwise you are trying to get a cutting to set root in wood, which will only work when the wood is in a serious state of decay. The reason your plant looked good is becaus juniperus is good at keeping moisture. If those so-called experts adviced you to graft upon a dead piece of wood, they are either no experts or they are pulling your leg. Sorry ..
by leatherback
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- KyleMB
-
Offline Topic Author
- New Member
-
- Posts: 16
- Thanks received: 0
@ Bassand名媛直播, Nice to meet you too! Thank you for that positive advice. Always good to hear an optimists point of view. 
@ Leatherback, Hi. I'm not sure why you are so doubtful of my project. Plants are incredible organisms and are capable of many things. I have carved out the piece of deadwood extensively. I have no doubt that my Juniper will grow to fill this groove and become part of the deadwood. You should consider trying new things and taking risks. It is the only way to make genuine progress. If it does not work this time, I will simply try again. "You only fail, when you fail to try again."
Nonetheless I appreciate everyone's opinion, thank you.

@ Leatherback, Hi. I'm not sure why you are so doubtful of my project. Plants are incredible organisms and are capable of many things. I have carved out the piece of deadwood extensively. I have no doubt that my Juniper will grow to fill this groove and become part of the deadwood. You should consider trying new things and taking risks. It is the only way to make genuine progress. If it does not work this time, I will simply try again. "You only fail, when you fail to try again."

Nonetheless I appreciate everyone's opinion, thank you.
by KyleMB
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- leatherback
-
Offline
- Platinum Member
-
- Posts: 8642
- Thanks received: 3662
Hi Kyle,
Although I am happy that you are so enthousiastic, the thing you want to do is just not going to happen. A dead plant, is just that: Dead. Consider the following: We know how to succesfully translant a human heart. However, if someone has had a heart failure, and you put the person in a cooler for a day, and then you bring a fresh heart to the person, you cannot make the person alive again. That is the same thing here.
A fresh branch that still has living cells in it you can get to resprout, grow roots etc. But a dead piece of wood cannot be used to succesfully graft branches on. It is not about experimenting, but it really is wasting effort. What you can do is fill the groove with a bit of soil and place cuttings in. THat might work. But grafting requires a living piece of bark, in order to supoprt the branch. I have been growing plants for over 25 year, and hold both an MSc and PhD in ecosystem biology with several published works on plant fysiology; I think I know what I am talking about here..
Although I am happy that you are so enthousiastic, the thing you want to do is just not going to happen. A dead plant, is just that: Dead. Consider the following: We know how to succesfully translant a human heart. However, if someone has had a heart failure, and you put the person in a cooler for a day, and then you bring a fresh heart to the person, you cannot make the person alive again. That is the same thing here.
A fresh branch that still has living cells in it you can get to resprout, grow roots etc. But a dead piece of wood cannot be used to succesfully graft branches on. It is not about experimenting, but it really is wasting effort. What you can do is fill the groove with a bit of soil and place cuttings in. THat might work. But grafting requires a living piece of bark, in order to supoprt the branch. I have been growing plants for over 25 year, and hold both an MSc and PhD in ecosystem biology with several published works on plant fysiology; I think I know what I am talking about here..
by leatherback
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- KyleMB
-
Offline Topic Author
- New Member
-
- Posts: 16
- Thanks received: 0
Ahh, I am afraid we have misunderstood one another. I do not want to revive the deadwood, I want it to remain dead. I simply want my tree to grow into the spaces and continue to grow alongside the deadwood.

by KyleMB
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.